The choice between a chic bucket bag and a do-it-all tote can be confusing.
The key difference is their shape and how you use them.
A bucket bag is stylish and cylindrical with a drawstring top, perfect for your daily essentials.
A tote bag is a large, rectangular bag with an open top, built to carry bigger items like a laptop or groceries.
But there is more to it than just their basic shapes.
The materials, size, and even how you carry them can make a big difference in your daily routine.
Let’s dive deeper into the details to help you find your perfect match.
What Is a Bucket Bag vs a Tote Bag?
Do you know what really separates these two bags?
They both carry your things, but their designs are for completely different needs and styles.
Here’s what sets them apart.
A bucket bag has a unique cylindrical shape, a round or oval bottom, and usually a drawstring closure.
A tote bag, on the other hand, is most often a rectangular or square bag with two matching handles and an open top for easy access.
Each bag has a very different structure that affects what you can carry and how you look carrying it.
A bucket bag’s design is often seen as more fashion-forward, while a tote bag is a timeless, practical choice for almost any situation.
Understanding these core differences is the first step in deciding which bag will become your go-to companion.
One is perfect for a light, stylish day out, while the other is ready to haul everything you need for a busy day.
The Bucket Bag Explained
A bucket bag gets its name from its shape.
It has a flat, round, or oval bottom that helps it stand upright on its own, which is a very handy feature.
From there, the bag rises into a cylinder-like body.
- Shape and Closure: The top of a bucket bag doesn’t usually have a zipper. Instead, it often closes with a drawstring that you pull to cinch it shut. Some might have a simple flap that folds over the top. This design keeps your belongings secure inside.
- How You Carry It: Most bucket bags come with a single long strap. This allows you to wear it over your shoulder or, more commonly, as a crossbody bag. Wearing it crossbody helps distribute the weight, making it comfortable for longer periods.
- The Vibe: Bucket bags often give off a chic and sophisticated vibe. Because their shape is so unique, they stand out more than a typical rectangular bag. In leather, they can look very classy and are a popular choice for people who want to add a stylish touch to their outfit.
The Tote Bag Explained
The tote bag is known for its simplicity and large capacity.
It is a true workhorse in the world of bags.
- Structure and Opening: Totes are almost always square or rectangular. Their biggest feature is a wide-open top, which makes it incredibly easy to put things in and take them out. While many are completely open, some modern totes have a simple snap button or even a full zipper for more security.
- How You Carry It: A tote bag always has two parallel handles. These handles are usually medium length, so you can carry the bag by hand or wear it over your shoulder.
- The Look: Totes are very versatile. A simple canvas tote can be super casual, perfect for grocery shopping or a trip to the beach. But a structured leather tote can look very polished and professional, making it a great choice for the office. People love them because they are perfect for carrying larger, flatter items like laptops, notebooks, and folders.
| Aspect | Bucket Bag | Tote Bag |
| Shape | Cylindrical with a round or oval base. | Rectangular or square. |
| Closure | Drawstring or flap. | Often an open top, but can have a snap or zipper. |
| Handles | Usually one long strap for crossbody or shoulder wear. | Two parallel handles for hand or shoulder carrying. |
| Best For | Daily essentials and making a fashion statement. | Carrying larger, flatter items like laptops, books, or groceries. |
Which Materials Are Common for Bucket Bags and Tote Bags?
Does the material of your bag really matter?
Yes, it changes the bag’s entire look, feel, weight, and how long it will last.
Let’s look at the most common choices.
Both bucket bags and tote bags are made from a variety of materials, most commonly leather, canvas, and synthetics like nylon or polyester.
Leather gives a classic, polished appearance.
Canvas is more casual and easy to clean, while nylon offers durability and water resistance, perfect for travel.
The material you choose affects more than just style.
It also determines how you’ll need to care for the bag and what situations it’s best suited for.
A leather bag might be perfect for your work week, but a canvas or nylon bag is probably a better choice for a weekend trip to the market or the beach.
Each fabric has its own set of pros and cons that are important to consider before you decide.
Leather
Leather is a classic choice that often gives bags a more upscale and polished look.
- Pros: Leather is very durable if you take care of it properly. It has a classy appearance that can elevate any outfit, making it great for professional settings or as a “statement” piece.
- Cons: The main downsides of leather are that it can be heavy, especially when you fill the bag up. It also requires regular care, like conditioning, to keep it from drying out or getting damaged by moisture.
In a bucket bag, leather provides structure at the base while allowing the top to remain flexible.
For totes, a sturdy leather construction looks clean and professional.
Canvas
Canvas is a go-to material for more casual, everyday bags.
- Pros: Canvas bags are very lightweight and often much more affordable than leather ones. Many are easy to clean, and some can even be machine-washed. It’s a great material for bags with fun prints or graphics.
- Cons: Unless it has a special coating, canvas can soak up water easily. It’s also a much more casual material, so it might not be the best fit for a formal or professional environment.
A canvas tote is the classic choice for running errands or heading to the beach.
Canvas bucket bags often have a relaxed, bohemian feel, especially with a simple drawstring.
Nylon and Polyester
These synthetic fabrics are all about practical performance.
- Pros: Nylon and polyester are known for being resistant to water, stains, and general wear and tear. They are usually more affordable than leather and are very lightweight, making them perfect for travel because they can be easily folded and stored.
- Cons: These materials may not have the same “luxury” feel as leather. Lower-quality versions can sometimes look or feel a bit “plasticky”.
Nylon totes are very popular for travel or as gym bags because they are so easy to wipe clean.
Bucket bags made from these materials can have a sporty or urban look.
How Do You Choose the Right Size for Each Bag?
Are you worried you’ll pick the wrong size?
A bag that’s too big can be a pain to carry, while a bag that’s too small is basically useless.
Here’s how to get it right.
You should pick the size of your bag based on what you need to carry every day.
Bucket bags work best for medium-sized loads, like your wallet, phone, and a few small accessories.
Tote bags are built for larger items, like laptops, books, or even a day’s worth of snacks.
The shape of the bag also plays a big role in what it can comfortably hold.
A bucket bag is tall and cylindrical, which is great for keeping items upright, but not so good for wide things like a folder or a laptop.
A tote bag’s wide, rectangular shape is much more forgiving for those bigger, flatter objects.
Thinking about your daily gear is the most important step to choosing a size that won’t let you down.
Sizing Up the Bucket Bag
Bucket bags are typically small to medium in size.
Their unique vertical design is perfect for carrying your daily essentials without feeling bulky.
- What It Fits: You can comfortably fit a phone, a small wallet, keys, and maybe a few other small items like lipstick or a compact umbrella.
- What It Doesn’t: Because of its tall and narrower shape, it’s not designed for big, flat items. Trying to stuff a laptop, a large book, or A4 documents inside just won’t work well.
- The Minimalist Choice: Using a bucket bag almost forces you to be a minimalist. You can only bring what truly fits, which helps reduce clutter. However, if you do overfill it, the narrow top can make it tricky to find what you’re looking for.
Sizing Up the Tote Bag
Tote bags are usually medium to large, designed to offer plenty of space.
- What It Fits: A tote can handle much more. It’s the perfect bag if you need to carry a book, a tablet or small laptop, a lunch container, or even your gym clothes. They are also the classic choice for a reusable shopping bag.
- The Risk of Overstuffing: The biggest advantage of a tote is also a potential downside. Because it’s so roomy, it’s easy to overstuff it. Carrying a heavy load in a tote bag can dig into your shoulder and cause strain or discomfort, especially if you’re walking a lot.
- Work and School Hero: If you need to carry a 13″ laptop or important documents daily, the accommodating shape of a tote bag is almost always the more practical and forgiving option.
Bucket Bag vs Tote Bag: Pros & Cons
Every bag has its good and bad points.
Knowing the pros and cons ahead of time can save you from regretting your purchase.
Let’s compare them side-by-side.
Bucket bags are praised for being stylish and secure, but their deep, unstructured shape can make it hard to find small items quickly.
Tote bags are incredibly spacious and versatile, but their open tops can lack security, and they can become bulky and uncomfortable on your shoulder when overloaded.
The “perfect” bag really depends on what you value more: a unique, fashionable silhouette or straightforward, roomy practicality.
One person’s favorite feature might be another person’s biggest complaint.
For example, the secure drawstring on a bucket bag is a big plus for some, but others find it too slow to open compared to a tote’s open top.
Let’s break down the advantages and disadvantages of each so you can decide what works best for your lifestyle.
Bucket Bag: The Good and The Bad
Pros:
- Stylish and Unique: The cylindrical shape of a bucket bag is distinctive and trendy, which can make any outfit look more fashionable. It’s an eye-catcher that stands out from more common bag shapes.
- Secure Closure: The drawstring or flap closure offers good security for your belongings, making it less likely for things to spill out or be easily reached by others.
- Comfortable to Carry: With a long crossbody strap, a bucket bag can distribute weight more evenly than a single-shoulder tote, making it comfortable for all-day wear.
- Stands Upright: The flat base on most bucket bags allows them to stand up on their own, preventing them from tipping over and making it easier to see inside.
Cons:
- Limited Organization: Most bucket bags have one large, open interior compartment. This can make it feel like a “bottomless pit” where small items like keys or lip balm get lost at the bottom.
- Tricky Access: Rummaging around inside a deep, narrow bag can be frustrating. The drawstring closure can also be slower to open and close compared to an open-top tote.
- Not for Large Items: The shape is not ideal for carrying bulky or flat items like laptops, folders, or books.
Tote Bag: The Good and The Bad
Pros:
- Incredibly Versatile: A tote bag can be used for almost anything: work, school, grocery shopping, the beach, or as a travel carry-on.
- High Capacity: Totes are designed to hold a lot of stuff. Their wide, open space is perfect for carrying heavier loads and larger items that wouldn’t fit in other bags.
- Easy Access: The open-top design allows you to quickly grab what you need without fussing with closures. This is great when you’re in a hurry.
- Can Be Organized: While some are simple, many modern totes come with interior pockets and compartments to help you organize your belongings.
Cons:
- Lack of Security: The biggest disadvantage is the open top on many totes. It can leave your belongings exposed and at risk of spilling if the bag tips over.
- Can Be Bulky: Because of their large size, totes can sometimes feel unwieldy or look bulky, especially for smaller individuals.
- Shoulder Strain: It’s easy to overload a tote bag, and carrying a heavy load on one shoulder can lead to discomfort and strain.
Conclusion
Your final choice depends on your lifestyle and priorities.
A tote is for practical days when you need to carry a lot, while a bucket bag is for stylish, lighter days.
Looking to Create Custom Handbags for Your Brand?
Partner with Veggance, a high-quality, eco-friendly handbag manufacturer dedicated to crafting innovative solutions for fashion-conscious consumers.
With over 15 years of experience in the handbag industry, we ensure efficiency and quality in every product, making us a trusted partner for renowned brands such as ZARA, C&A, and Disney.
If you need to customize handbags for your brand, contact us today to bring your vision to life!
FAQ
Are bucket bags still in style?
Yes, they are definitely still in style. Designers frequently release new versions in different colors, textures, and with updated details, keeping them a modern and popular choice.
Why are tote bags so popular?
Tote bags are popular because they are incredibly practical, roomy, and simple. Their no-frills design makes them perfect for a wide variety of daily tasks, from work to shopping.
Can a bucket bag look professional?
Absolutely. A bucket bag made from refined leather with sleek, minimal hardware can look very classy and sophisticated, making it a great choice for business-casual settings.
What is the main disadvantage of a tote bag?
The biggest disadvantage is often the lack of a secure closure on basic models, which can risk spillage or theft. Another common issue is shoulder strain from carrying heavy loads.
Is a bucket bag good for traveling?
It can be, especially if it’s made of a lightweight material like nylon. However, for carrying travel documents, a laptop, and other essentials, a tote is often more practical due to its larger capacity and easier access.
How can I keep my bucket bag organized?
A great way to keep a bucket bag organized is to use small pouches or bag organizers inside. This helps separate your items and prevents everything from falling into a jumble at the bottom.
Which bag is better for school or work?
For school or work, a tote bag is generally the better option because it has enough space to easily carry laptops, books, and documents.
Do tote bags always have an open top?
Not always. While the classic design is an open-top bag, many modern totes now include a snap button or a full zipper closure for added security.